Skip to content
The Long Horizon
The Long Horizon

The longer car loan is now the cheaper one

Every year since 2023 said the opposite. The card rate, meanwhile, went up.

The longer car loan is now the cheaper one

The Horizon

A car loan written this past spring on a six-year term will still be collecting payments in 2032. The rate stamped on it is fixed for that entire distance, whatever the funds rate does in between.

Households signed a great deal of that paper over the summer. Tuesday afternoon put both the pace and the price on the record.

The price is the stranger half of it. Banks have started charging less for the longer contract than for the shorter one.

None of that is a forecast, and it cannot be. These are signed contracts with maturity dates already printed on them.

The Event

The Federal Reserve released its G.19 consumer credit report for July on Tuesday, September 8, at 3 p.m. Eastern. Total consumer credit grew at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 4.2%.

The mix flipped inside one month. Revolving credit slowed to a 2.5% annual rate while nonrevolving credit accelerated to 4.8%, against June readings of 6.0% and 2.5%.

Balances stood at $1,357.2 billion revolving and $3,829.0 billion nonrevolving, for $5,186.2 billion in total. The series excludes loans secured by real estate, so no part of that figure is mortgage debt.

For the second quarter as a whole the total ran at 2.9%, revolving at 4.9% and nonrevolving at 2.2%. July broke that pattern in both directions at once.

The same release carries a quarterly survey of what commercial banks charge. It put the 60-month new car loan at 7.14% in the second quarter and the 72-month at 6.97%.

In the first quarter both terms priced identically at 7.53%. In every annual and quarterly column the release shows back to 2023, the 72-month rate sat above the 60-month, by 6 basis points in 2023 and by 26 in the fourth quarter of 2025.

Sponsored

P.I.P. partnerships went up 7.2%. The S&P lost 4.1

On February 28, Iran's Supreme Leader was killed. In the aftermath of that assassination…

  • The Strait of Hormuz closed.
  • 20% of global oil was blocked.
  • Oil prices hit $117 a barrel.

But through it all…

The 11 partnerships inside the Patriot Income Plan [P.I.P.] went up 7.2%, on average.

The S&P lost 4.1%.

Even more impressive…

All 11 partnerships inside P.I.P. kept paying distributions to investors.

Together they produced 79% total combined gains.

Why? Because the partnerships inside P.I.P. make money from America's energy infrastructure regardless of whether we're at war or not.

So when the world scrambled for energy, P.I.P. produced more revenue.

More revenue led to bigger distributions.

And with the war still raging…

The thesis behind P.I.P. isn't theory anymore, it's been battle-tested.

This plan not only pays you 42 times a year.

It also averages a 10% yield.

The next payout is days away.

Enroll in P.I.P. NOW.

P.S. Since 2020, the average partnership in P.I.P. has produced 20% avg. annual gains. That's in addition to the 10% yield. One investor already collects $4,800 a month. Another hasn't worked in years. Show me something better. I'll wait.

[Enroll in P.I.P. →]

The Path

A rate that falls as the term lengthens is not a shape any bond market produces. It is the shape of a lender choosing which contract to compete for.

Seventeen basis points of inversion after three years of the opposite says the competition moved to the six-year note rather than the five. That choice sets the monthly payment on the second largest purchase most households make.

Auto paper does not stay with the bank that writes it. A large share is pooled and sold as asset-backed securities, and nonrevolving growth running at 4.8% is the supply pipeline for that collateral.

Insurance general accounts and short-duration bond funds hold the resulting bonds. The average life of what they buy next year is being set now, at dealerships, by whichever term lenders priced most cheaply.

The card side went the other way. The same survey put the rate on all credit card accounts at 20.94% in the second quarter, and the rate on accounts actually assessed interest at 22.15%, up from 21.52% three months earlier.

The target range for the federal funds rate is 3.50% to 3.75%. Roughly seventeen points separate the cheapest overnight money in the system from the most expensive liability on a household balance sheet.

That gap matters inside a retirement account in a way no statement records. Contributions compound at whatever an index returns, a revolving balance compounds at 20.94%, and only the second of those two rates is contractual.

Nonrevolving credit is the slower series by construction. A card balance can disappear in a month, while an auto or student loan unwinds on a schedule fixed years earlier.

Student loans stood at $1,858.2 billion and motor vehicle loans at $1,574.8 billion as of the second quarter. Both keep paying out long after the month that produced them stops being news.

The Watch

Four readings bear on this, and they arrive on four completely different clocks. The nearest one is two days away.

Friday at noon brings the Z.1 Financial Accounts of the United States, which reports the asset side of the household balance sheet whose liabilities printed Tuesday. Liabilities grew at 4.2% annualized in July, and Friday says what the other column did.

A week further on, the rate decision arrives with a fresh set of committee projections. None of it reaches the card rate, which is the part worth holding onto.

Four weeks out, the October 7 release carries the August terms-of-credit survey. That is the first test of whether the inversion was one quarter of aggressive lending or the new shape of the thing.

The last clock runs to 2032, when the six-year loans written this spring finish paying. Everything above it is provisional.

Keep reading

Continue along the horizon.

View more
Think in years

If you value resilience over reaction, and compounding over speculation, subscribe.